Criminal Sentencing and Legal Validity Evaluation on LeCaRD v2
9.98RMSEL4L
Evaluation Results
| Method | Links | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| L4LStatute Provision=w/ Golden Statute2025.11 | 9.98 | 96.2 | |
| LexGuardGolden Statutes=with2026.05 | 9.98 | 96.2 | |
| L4LStatute Provision=w/o Golden Statute2025.11 | 12.72 | 94.6 | |
| LexGuardGolden Statutes=without2026.05 | 12.72 | 94.6 | |
| GPT 5.2Statute Provision=w/ Golden Statute2025.11 | 13.87 | 94 | |
| GPT 3.5Golden Statutes=with2026.05 | 13.87 | 94 | |
| GPT 5.2Statute Provision=w/o Golden Statute2025.11 | 14.54 | 94.2 | |
| GPT 3.5Golden Statutes=without2026.05 | 14.54 | 94.2 | |
| DeepSeek v3Statute Provision=w/ Golden Statute2025.11 | 15.42 | 93 | |
| DeepSeek v3Golden Statutes=with2026.05 | 15.42 | 93 | |
| GPT-4oStatute Provision=w/ Golden Statute2025.11 | 22.68 | 95 | |
| GPT-4oGolden Statutes=with2026.05 | 22.68 | 95 | |
| Claude 4 SonnetStatute Provision=w/ Golden Statute2025.11 | 26.2 | 94 | |
| Claude 4 SonnetGolden Statutes=with2026.05 | 26.2 | 94 | |
| Claude 4 SonnetStatute Provision=w/o Golden Statute2025.11 | 26.25 | 93 | |
| Claude 4 SonnetGolden Statutes=without2026.05 | 26.25 | 93 | |
| DeepSeek v3Statute Provision=w/o Golden Statute2025.11 | 26.73 | 64.3 | |
| DeepSeek v3Golden Statutes=without2026.05 | 26.73 | 64.3 | |
| GPT o4-miniStatute Provision=w/ Golden Statute2025.11 | 28.03 | 94 | |
| GPT o4-miniGolden Statutes=with2026.05 | 28.03 | 94 | |
| LexiLawStatute Provision=w/ Golden Statute2025.11 | 28.51 | 90 | |
| LexiLawGolden Statutes=with2026.05 | 28.51 | 90 | |
| GPT-4oStatute Provision=w/o Golden Statute2025.11 | 32.84 | 94 | |
| GPT-4oGolden Statutes=without2026.05 | 32.84 | 94 | |
| GPT o4-miniStatute Provision=w/o Golden Statute2025.11 | 33.2 | 92 | |
| GPT o4-miniGolden Statutes=without2026.05 | 33.2 | 92 | |
| DISC-LawLLMStatute Provision=w/ Golden Statute2025.11 | 37.14 | 90 | |
| DISC-LawLLMGolden Statutes=with2026.05 | 37.14 | 90 | |
| LexiLawStatute Provision=w/o Golden Statute2025.11 | 39.09 | 92.13 | |
| LexiLawGolden Statutes=without2026.05 | 39.09 | 92.13 | |
| DISC-LawLLMStatute Provision=w/o Golden Statute2025.11 | 52.45 | 83 | |
| DISC-LawLLMGolden Statutes=without2026.05 | 52.45 | 83 |