Atlas Building on OAI knee MRI NIMH Data Archive Collection ID: 2343 (test)
96.27Volume Dice (Bone)Aladdin
Evaluation Results
| Method | Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AladdinAffine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Learning, Similarity Measure=NCC, Pairwise Similarity Loss=false, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 96.27 | 75.11 | 85.69 | 31.61 | |
| AladdinAffine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.4), Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=true, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 96.09 | 74.86 | 85.48 | 7.95 | |
| AladdinAffine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Learning, Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=false, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 96.08 | 74.39 | 85.24 | 6.74 | |
| AladdinAffine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Learning, Similarity Measure=NCC, Pairwise Similarity Loss=false, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 96.03 | 73.86 | 84.94 | 53.03 | |
| AladdinAffine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.4), Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=false, Pairwise Regularization Loss=false, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 95.83 | 74.16 | 84.99 | 36.82 | |
| AladdinAffine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.4), Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=false, Pairwise Regularization Loss=false, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 95.81 | 73.97 | 84.89 | 14.54 | |
| AladdinAffine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Learning, Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=false, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 95.77 | 73.06 | 84.41 | 18.86 | |
| Dalca et al.Affine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Learning, Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=true, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 95.72 | 74.18 | 84.95 | 86.35 | |
| Dalca et al.Affine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Learning, Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=true, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 95.71 | 72.47 | 84.09 | 133.55 | |
| AladdinAffine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.4), Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=true, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 95.71 | 73.74 | 84.72 | 26 | |
| Dalca et al.Affine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Learning, Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=false, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 95.69 | 73.54 | 84.62 | 131.2 | |
| Dalca et al.Affine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Learning, Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=false, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 95.29 | 72.48 | 83.89 | 78.97 | |
| Joshi et al.Affine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.3), Similarity Measure=MSE, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 95.18 | 73.84 | 84.51 | 37.49 | |
| VoxelmorphAffine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.4), Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=true, Pairwise Regularization Loss=false, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 95.13 | 72.03 | 83.58 | 476.45 | |
| Dalca et al.Affine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Learning, Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=false, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 95.07 | 63.27 | 79.17 | 96.76 | |
| Joshi et al.Affine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.3), Similarity Measure=MSE, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 94.98 | 73.58 | 84.28 | 24.39 | |
| Dalca et al.Affine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Learning, Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=false, Pairwise Regularization Loss=true, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 94.53 | 61.55 | 78.04 | 116.3 | |
| He et al.Affine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.3), Similarity Measure=NCC, Pairwise Similarity Loss=true, Pairwise Regularization Loss=false, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 93.95 | 61.44 | 77.7 | 51.76 | |
| He et al.Affine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.3), Similarity Measure=NCC, Pairwise Similarity Loss=true, Pairwise Regularization Loss=false, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 93.65 | 60.82 | 77.24 | 34.99 | |
| VoxelmorphAffine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.3), Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=true, Pairwise Regularization Loss=false, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 93.09 | 73.37 | 83.23 | 15.47 | |
| ABSORBAffine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Hierarchical, Similarity Measure=MSE, Evaluation Protocol=C_atlas_image2022.02 | 93.04 | 73.34 | 83.19 | 18.76 | |
| VoxelmorphAffine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.4), Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=true, Pairwise Regularization Loss=false, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 91.91 | 60.06 | 75.99 | 482.82 | |
| VoxelmorphAffine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.3), Similarity Measure=MSE, Pairwise Similarity Loss=true, Pairwise Regularization Loss=false, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 91.47 | 59.99 | 75.73 | 272.22 | |
| ABSORBAffine Pre-alignment=true, Atlas Acquisition=Hierarchical, Similarity Measure=MSE, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 91.16 | 59.13 | 75.15 | 237.04 | |
| AffineAffine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.3), Similarity Measure=MSE, Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 90.35 | 38.44 | 64.39 | 0 | |
| NoneAffine Pre-alignment=false, Atlas Acquisition=Eq. (2.3), Evaluation Protocol=Atlas-as-a-bridge2022.02 | 76.7 | 0 | 38.37 | 0 |