# When Reviewers Lock Horn: Finding Disagreement in Scientific Peer Reviews

Source: [When Reviewers Lock Horn: Finding Disagreement in Scientific Peer Reviews](<https://www.sota2.com/research/paper/68fa71041e209131cea4e96a>)

Collection index: [llms.txt](<https://www.sota2.com/research/llms.txt>)

Data updated: 2025-10-26T01:55:42.510Z

Authors: Sandeep Kumar, Tirthankar Ghosal, Asif Ekbal

Published: 2023-10-28T11:57:51.000Z

## Abstract

To this date, the efficacy of the scientific publishing enterprise fundamentally rests on the strength of the peer review process. The journal editor or the conference chair primarily relies on the expert reviewers' assessment, identify points of agreement and disagreement and try to reach a consensus to make a fair and informed decision on whether to accept or reject a paper. However, with the escalating number of submissions requiring review, especially in top-tier Artificial Intelligence (AI) conferences, the editor/chair, among many other works, invests a significant, sometimes stressful effort to mitigate reviewer disagreements. Here in this work, we introduce a novel task of automatically identifying contradictions among reviewers on a given article. To this end, we introduce ContraSciView, a comprehensive review-pair contradiction dataset on around 8.5k papers (with around 28k review pairs containing nearly 50k review pair comments) from the open review-based ICLR and NeurIPS conferences. We further propose a baseline model that detects contradictory statements from the review pairs. To the best of our knowledge, we make the first attempt to identify disagreements among peer reviewers automatically. We make our dataset and code public for further investigations.

## Recorded benchmark results

A research result applies to its stated dataset, split, metric and evaluation configuration. Compare like-for-like settings, preserve the metric's unit and direction, and distinguish paper-reported results from independent reproduction. The best result recorded here is not a claim of exhaustive, current global coverage.

- [Contradiction Detection on RevCI (test)](<https://www.sota2.com/research/sota/contradiction-detection-on-revci-test.md>): Contradiction detection; RevCI (test); FNR: 39.2.

## Original sources and implementation

[Original paper](<https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.18685>)

[PDF](<https://arxiv.org/pdf/2310.18685.pdf>)
