# Reply to Lindgren and Salomonson

Source: [Reply to Lindgren and Salomonson](<https://www.sota2.com/research/paper/68fa1fca7a2b558e2932c400>)

Collection index: [llms.txt](<https://www.sota2.com/research/llms.txt>)

Data updated: 2025-10-23T19:39:46.431Z

Authors: R. K. Nesbet

Published: 2003-09-29T21:48:27.000Z

## Abstract

In the accompanying Comment \[Phys. Rev. A {\\bf 67}, 056501 (2003)\], I. Lindgren and S. Salomonson claim to prove for the Kohn-Sham kinetic energy functional of ground state electron density that a Fr\\"echet functional derivative exists, equivalent to a multiplicative local potential function. If true, this result would imply an exact Thomas-Fermi theory for ground states of noninteracting electrons. However, such a theory is not consistent with the exclusion principle for more than one electron of each spin. The simplest counterexample is the lowest triplet state of a noninteracting two-electron atom. If only the total electron density were normalized, as in Thomas-Fermi theory, the lowest state would collapse into a doubly-occupied $1s$ spin-orbital. Two independent parameters $\\epsilon\_{1s}$ and $\\epsilon\_{2s}$ are required to maintain independent subshell normalization. The argument presented by these authors is discussed in the light of this unphysical implication.

## Recorded benchmark results

A research result applies to its stated dataset, split, metric and evaluation configuration. Compare like-for-like settings, preserve the metric's unit and direction, and distinguish paper-reported results from independent reproduction. The best result recorded here is not a claim of exhaustive, current global coverage.

## Original sources and implementation

[Original paper](<https://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0309121>)

[PDF](<https://arxiv.org/pdf/physics/0309121.pdf>)
